News

crane hooks are key load-bearing components, and the comparison between imported and domestic products requires a multi-dimensional analysis of materials, processes, standards, costs, and applicability. The following is a detailed comparison and selection recommendations:

1. Core Difference Comparison

2. Suggestions for applicable scenarios

When imported hooks are preferred

1. Extreme working conditions : frequent heavy loads (≥80% rated load), low temperatures (<-20°C), and corrosive environments (such as offshore platforms).

2. Regulatory Compulsion : Exported equipment must comply with mandatory items of CE/ASME certification.

3. Long-cycle demand : scenarios with continuous production and high downtime costs (such as continuous casting machines in steel plants).

When domestic hooks are preferred

1. Conventional working conditions : indoor operation, small load fluctuation (such as 5-10 ton lifting in warehouses).

2. Cost-sensitive : Limited budget or need to reserve multiple types of spare hooks.

3. Quick response : emergency replacement needs (e.g. domestic hooks can be purchased or customized locally).

3. Progress and Challenges of Domestic Lifting Hooks

• Technological advancements :

  • Leading manufacturers (such as Henan Weihua and Jiangsu Sanma) have introduced German forging equipment, and the UT testing coverage has increased to 100%.

  • The application of new 42CrMoV alloy steel has narrowed the fatigue life gap.

• Existing shortcomings :

  • Small manufacturers still sell inferior products as good ones (using Q235 to impersonate alloy steel);

  • High-precision thread processing (such as hook shank thread) has a low yield rate.

4. Key points of purchasing decision

1. Verification test report :

   • Imported products must provide the original material certificate (MTC) + third-party flaw detection report (such as SGS);

   • Domestic products are subject to verification of the Special Equipment Manufacturing License (TSG).

2. Cost-Benefit Analysis :

   • Calculate TCO (Total Cost of Ownership): Although the unit price of imported hooks is high, the longer replacement cycle may be more economical.
     Example: The service life of imported hooks is 8 years vs. 5 years for domestic ones, and the long-term maintenance cost is reduced by 30%.

3. Supplier Evaluation :

   • Imported brands: Investigate the technical support capabilities of domestic agents (e.g. after-sales response ≤ 24 hours);

   • Domestic brands: give priority to enterprises that participate in the formulation of national standards (such as supporting suppliers of Shanghai Zhenhua Heavy Industries).

5. Typical Brand Reference

• Imported brands :

  • RUD (Germany): Leading lamination hook technology, suitable for the metallurgical industry.

  • Crosby (USA): Mainstream supplier of American standard hooks, the first choice for the oil industry.

• Domestic brands :

  • Henan Weihua : Drafting unit of GB/T 10051 standard, high cost performance.

  • Jiangsu Sanma : Focus on heavy forged hooks, exporting to Southeast Asian market.

Summary and recommendations

• High-end fields (nuclear power, deep sea): choose imported hooks to ensure safety;

• General industry (logistics, construction): domestic high-quality hooks + strict testing, better cost performance;

• Hybrid strategy : Import the main hook and use domestically produced auxiliary hook/spare hook to balance safety and cost.

It is recommended to entrust a third party (such as TÜV) to conduct a sampling load test (125% rated load test) based on the specific working conditions to verify the actual performance gap.